Arianna Martinez directs a captivating exploration of reality and identity. Olive and Benny are spending an ordinary day at their lake house when strange things start happening—a misplaced package, scrambled letters on the fridge, and then something profound: Benny is suddenly replaced by a woman named Ada, who insists she’s been Olive’s partner for years. Co-writing with producer Gordon Mihan, Martinez crafts a narrative that’s slippery and strange. Caroline Bell shines in her debut as Olive, questioning the life she’s been living. Do I Know You From Somewhere? is a wonderfully unsettling journey that lingers long after it ends.